Category Archives: Sessions

Tanks – BEF Breakthrough Pt I

Decided to get on it and set up Tanks downstairs.  First chance to use BEF armor.

Threw out tiles and randomly slapped terrain mats down for a fight between Matildas and light German armor.

British orders were for the the Matildas to exploit a breakthrough (a quasi often gamed Arras maybe-it-would-have-been-something-decisive scenario).

After much wailing and gnashing of teeth I settled on ratings for the Matildas.

The Two Matilda Marks At The Top
The Pz II Defense Rating Should Be A “1”

The machine gun armed Matilda I is virtually useless against armor, but can hammer German infantry.  The Matilda IIs guided the little waddlers, while fending off the German armor.

The Panzers pressed their attacks, but the combination of British armor thickness and good die rolls were too much.

Matilda IIs Protecting The Little Matilda Is
Panzer 38ts Destroyed In Close Combat

Another fun, fast game.  Next up……Matildas vs. The Panzer Varsity (Mk IIIs and MK IVs).

Third World War -Tim’s Take

Here are his thoughts……

> 1)  I either should have reinforced my amphibious landing or withdrawn it.  I think it was a good idea, but the execution was a little flawed.  The Pact player has to take some risks to get across the Bosphorus.  Like the Rhine, it is almost impossible to breach using regular units.
> 2)  I wonder if it would be a good idea for the Yugoslavs to withdraw to Sarajevo and form a national redoubt.  they would probably last longer and tie down more Pact troops if they did.  I’m not familiar with Yugoslav defense planning in the 80s but I bet they actually thought about doing something similar (ie that plan might not be all that gamey…).
> 3)  My poor rolling on aircraft maintenance on turn 2 really hurt.  I was thinking about attacking Istanbul, but without air support, I had very little chance of taking it (basically I had to hope for an exchange).
> 4)  I wonder if it would be a good idea for NATO to use its air power in the first subimpulses of the Pact turn.  Pact units can’t attack during the second subimpulse if they’re in a ZOC and lowering the odds so attacks don’t succeed (meaning that the defenders don’t retreat) prevents units from being to move/attack in the second sub impulse.

 

 

 

Third World War

Played Southern Front from the old GDW Third World War series last weekend at Tim’s.

Much lower counter density than Battle For Germany, and with very tough victory conditions for the Warsaw Pact.

Victory points are awarded for controlling cities and ports, and the Pact must control almost every city and port in Yugoslavia (if hostile), Greece and Turkey to score a decisive victory.

The NATO player is outmanned and outgunned, and must grimly hang on during a seemingly endless series of Pact high odds attacks.

While the game is only eight turns long, each turn is lengthy and involved.

Aircraft maintenance and missions assignment occurs before any movement takes place.  Aircraft can fly deep strikes including logistical strikes (effecting supply status), runway cratering, or escort; interdiction missions resulting in additional movement costs and disruption for enemy units, as well as plain old ground attack and ground attack escort missions.

Movement and combat takes place in impulses.  The turn sequence is Pact First Impulse (movement and combat), Pact Sub Impulse (units not in enemy ZOCs may move and attack, with regroup), a NATO Reserve Impulse (units not in enemy ZOCs may move and attack, units may also regroup), Pact Second Impulse (same as first with two sub-impulses) , and finally a NATO First and Second Impulse.

A key element in this game system is Proficiency Rating.  Differences in ratings shift combat odds in the favor of the side with higher average proficiency.  The regroup phase allows players to “rebuild” units, recovering one proficiency step if the unit has not done anything in the previous phase and is not in an enemy ZOC.  Pact units can never be totally “rebuilt” and retain a one factor proficiency loss, regardless.

Yugoslavia is either neutral, an ally of NATO, or becomes a NATO ally during Turn 4.  This determination by a chit pull.

A special rule in Southern Front precludes any NATO deep strikes, cratering or escort missions during the first turn.  Also, the NATO initial ground dispositions are mandated.  The result is that the first Pact impulses result in significant attrition of NATO Turkish forces, with the Greeks taking some hits, also.  Not surprisingly, Turks and Greeks cannot cooperate or enter each other’s country.

In our game, Tim initially focused on Turkey, making an amphibious landing east of Istanbul, which is the bottleneck leading to Anatolia.   Despite severe losses, the Turks held  Istanbul and, with the arrival of reinforcement, destroyed the flanking Soviet Marines.  Tim’s attempts were handicapped by some horrific die rolling during the maintenance phase of Turn 2, which temporarily gave NATO air superiority.

Beginning with Turn 3, Tim’s attention  turned towards Yugoslavia (which had entered on Turn 1), and Greece.  When the game ended at Turn 5, the Yugoslavs were in disarray, with Pact forces massing for an attack on Greece.  However, Turkey was still controlled by NATO.

A good game.  I’ll post up Tim’s comments later.

Early War Tanks

Had a quick game this afternoon.

Used my draft cards for early-war German and Soviet armor.  They are a real beta given my lack of proofing and child-like work with the scissors.

A Pz-II and Pz-38t tasked with stopping a break-thru by a BT-5 and two Soviet T-26s.

Terrain was placed helter skelter.  Both sides used maximum maneuver to take advantage of terrain and the accompanying speed defense modifiers.

Fun little game.  Germans had an early edge using their higher initiative ratings, but just couldn’t put away the Soviets, especially with the Pz-II’s popgun of a 20mm worth only one die in the attack.  But, they almost pulled it off.

Here’s a few photos.

Early Maneuvering. Pz-38t Heads To The Woods.  New Card In Foreground.
Pz-II Sets Up For Flank Shot On BT-5.
Attacking The Pz-38t Now In The Woods.  German Wants Cover/Stationary Mods.
PZ 38t Leaves Woods Trying For Point Blank Flanking Shot On T-26.  Iron Dice Of War Say NO.
Iron Dice Of War Say BLAMMO! BT-5 Gets The Pz-II.
Pz-II Burns Unavenged While Its Kamerad Flees.  German Counterattack Fails.

Tim’s Take

Tim sent me his (always trenchant) comments.  Here they are:

    • I was curious about how much population is contained in city spaces (14).  In light of this weekend’s games, a good strategy for the US is to focus on pacifying the cities (14 x 2= 28) and keeping the commitment low (you had 22 available troops), as it is hard for the insurgent player to counter.  I had trouble moving guerrillas into the cities and keeping them alive…
    • A good counter to the above strategy is to kill off US troops.  I didn’t do a very good job of hunting them down (and you were good about not putting them in exposed positions).  I had hoped to run some bombardment operations but either my troops were in the wrong place or I had to do something else…
    • Another possible counter is the one I stumbled upon in the last game: the VC wins the hearts and minds of the countryside and just enough of the cities to get the win.
    • I was surprised at how the lack of resources really hampers the insurgent player.  I got a little frustrated during the first game because it seemed just when the NVA was ready to intervene, you would play an event card to either reduce or eliminate their resources.
    • The ARVN and VC were much more active in this weekend’s games than in our earlier games, which were dominated by the US and the NVA.  The VC ability to subvert enemy troops makes them fun to play (you showed admirable forbearance in the face of my constant cries of ‘terror and subvert’….).  The ARVN troops gave me trouble in the second game and played a big role in holding the line until you could bring your airstrikes to bear.
    • I missed a trick when I didn’t move the NVA troops into provinces that supported you.  I know you would have bombed them anyway, but the price would have been higher.
    • Did you know that NVA troops can be used for terror operations?  I didn’t notice that until midway through the second game (there is a lot of nuance in this game).  I wonder if it would be a good idea for the NVA to send in small groups of troops for terror ops and maybe picking off the occasional enemy unit.
    • Did you know that NVA guerrillas can set up in the south?  For some reason, I’d gotten it in my head that they couldn’t.
    • I kept too many units back to defend bases.  I probably should have pushed more units forward into the fray…I think it wouldn’t be a bad idea to put more than one base in area so as to cut down on the numbers of defenders.

 

Maximum Effort

Tim came over the mountain last Saturday for a weekend of wargaming.   Spent Saturday afternoon/evening catching up and turned to on Sunday.  Many Private Reserves and Blue Boars were consumed.

Completed two (yes, two!) games of the two-player version of Fire in the Lake.  Finished up at 2310.  How?  We actually stayed on task (no football, especially if you count The Pro-Bowl), and the Coup Cards popped up sooner rather than later.  Coup Cards determine the end of a turn and also the an accounting for determining victory points.

There were three consistent threads in our talks during the games.  The first was how different the character of each game was, and the accompanying re-playability.  It’s a spendy game, but sure worth it.

The second was how tough it was to play.  Not the rules, how the card flow created the decisions that had to be made under less than ideal operational conditions.  There never seemed to be a direct path to accomplishing mission goals.  Who was that, Wolfe?  “War is an option of difficulties.”

The third focused on how each of the four sides had conflicting goals, and the impact on operations and results.  This is a great four player game.  The problem is finding four players.

US strategy emphasized pacification (with accompanying support), using air strikes and irregulars to attrit communists.  This was accomplished using a minimum of US troops.  ARVN troops would sweep to locate enemy guerrillas, so they could be bombed, with ARVN Rangers raiding provinces to destroy guerrillas.  In both games, the South Vietnamese were used to attain US victory points.

Both communist factions are hampered by a lack of resources.  As a result, their operations featured taxes, but also using terror to reduce support.  Infiltration was another favorite tactic since ARVN troops or police could be eliminated or “flipped”.

Both games followed the historical pattern of the US/ARVN forces controlling cities and VC controlling the countryside.  The first game was a US victory, the second was a tie between  the US and VC.

Great weekend of gaming with a great game.  Here’s photo of the end-game for game number 2.

Not For The Faint Of Heart

Been hacking away at D-Day At Omaha Beach by Decision Games.  Highly regarded over at Boardgamegeek.

Since it’s solitaire, several charts and card draws used each turn.  No dice, however.  Reminds me of RAF, and it should since it has the same designer.  Also reminds me of In Magnificent Style, as you take a beating, only this time on the beaches.  I’m just trying to keep all  the graphic Saving Private Ryan scenes out of my head (no, won’t insert a link to that).

Right now, the hacking part is playing through the rules, with little regard to tactics/beating the system.  Reading them is always the easy part.

The development team did everyone a favor by creating an introductory scenario using only the 1st Division and half the map.  While the separate color examples of play pamphlet is very helpful, it would be better to get the full GMT-Type Playbook treatment when beginning to play.

Seems to deserve all of the praise it’s received.  Will continue to split board game time with this and ASLSK.

Taking A Breather

Putting Irregular Wars away for awhile.  Good stopping point, with a need to determine the outcomes after the Battle At The Oasis Of Olufunke.

What happens to Lord Renaldo’s army?

1) Disintegrates/Retreats to coast; 2) Alliance with Natives; 3) Fight Natives; 4)Alliance with Bey Mahir to fight Sultan Efe.

What happens to the victorious Bey Mahir?

1) No further action; 2) Attacks Natives; 3) Alliance with Natives and/or 4) Attacks Sultan Efe:

What happens to Sultan Efe?

1) Decided after Lord Renaldo/Bey Mahir outcome(s).

Do Ming Chinese become involved?

1)  Yes/No; 2)  If Yes, how?

Do Natives become involved?

1) Decided after Lord Renaldo/Bey Mahir outcomes(s).

We’ll see…..

 

Carnage At Olufunke

Remnants of Lord Renaldo’s army have fled south after a stunning defeat at the Oasis At Olufunke.  The Bey’s army is too worn to pursue, having suffered heavy losses in a battle that had three distinct phases.

Bey Mahir’s defensive alignment was a variation of what he had used before.   His units were arrayed in a checkerboard along the entire plain lying south of the oasis.  His Civic Guard units were in front, with Tribal units some distance to the rear, but filling the gaps between Guard units.  This would allow any wavering guards to fall back unimpeded and tribesmen to counterattack.  Renaldo’s plan was use his Shot and Bow units as a screen on his right (Zanj left), while his Pike and Targeteer units concentrated on his left (Zanj right) to deliver a crushing blow to enemies to their front.

The Disease and Mishap rolls were not kind to the Zanj.  Four units lost resolve due to illness and two units were pushed out of position.  Once again, the skill of the Portuguese surgeon saved Renaldo’s army from any loss of resolve.

Opening Dispositions After Rolls For Disease and Mishaps.

First Phase:

The Portuguese screening force was extremely effective, engaging the Zanj guardsmen at long range, causing most of them to scatter.  They could not close and melee with the weaker Portuguese.  More importantly,the guardsmen could not be rallied since their retreat drove them out of the Bey’s command radius.  However, the Bey’s forces on his right stopped the Portuguese Pike and Targeteer onslaught, locking them in attritional melees.  It was here that the effect of the earlier battle, which lowered the morale (and resolve) of the Portuguese, was critical.  The Portuguese were wearing down.

Melee On The Portuguese Left. Mercenaries Flanked. Civic Guard Unit Moves To Contain Portuguese Break-Through

Second Phase:

Desperate to break this deadlock, Renaldo ordered his Shot and Bow units to close to within short range of the decimated Zanj units. His hope was to gain the initiative on the next move.  If so, these units could deliver devastating volleys, scattering the Zanj units to his right, forcing a general withdrawal.  The Iron Dice Of War crushed his hopes.  The Portuguese lost the initiative, with Zanj units driving both Shot and Bow units back in disarray.

Portuguese Shot and Bow Move To Close Range

Portuguese Right Collapses. Lord Renaldo’s Personal Guard Attacks

Lord Renaldo launched a last ditch assault with his personal guard of Targeteers, scattering three Zanj units.  However, the outnumbered Zanj units somehow stopped the continued attacks of the Portuguese of the Portuguese Pike.

Third Phase:

Now the desperate one, Bey Mahir attacked Lord Renaldo’s guard.  After a prolonged fight, Renaldo’s unit scattered opening the way for flanking attacks on his remaining units.

Surrounded, Renaldo’s Personal Guard Will Scatter

The Portuguese had no choice but to flee.

Portuguese, Covered By The (Now) Valiant Mercenaries Withdraw To The West

Battle At The Oasis of Olufunke – Preliminaries

The Bey’s instincts were correct.  He quickly raised four more Civic Guard units, giving him nine.  His Tribesmen were relatively intact after the battle, and add another five units to his army.  The Civic Guards confidence and resolve soared as a result of their staunch performance, and all units are now rated a “3”.  The Bey’s experience now allows him to have a command radius of six units.

The Portuguese were shaken  by the seeming setback at the Faragh.   The resolve of their Pike units has dropped to “4”, with the Musketeer units resolve now at “3”.   Lord Renaldo’s  negotiated settlement with the Persian mercenaries  is the one bright spot in this deteriorating situation.

A condition of employment was to reveal the ringleaders of their desertion from the Bey’s army.  That being done, Lord Renaldo personally executed them in front of his army.  Now “encouraged”, the Persians have a resolve of “4”.

The Bey’s forces have taken up positions at the Oasis, and the Portuguese approach.  The battle is at hand…….